Behind the film
- Year
- 1983
- Director
- John Landis
- Writers
- Timothy Harris, Herschel Weingrod
- Runtime
- 1h 56m
- Genres
- Comedy, Christmas
- Production
- Paramount Pictures
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Dan Aykroyd, Eddie Murphy, Ralph Bellamy, Don Ameche, Denholm Elliott, Jamie Lee Curtis, Paul Gleason, Frank Oz
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Randolph and Mortimer Duke run a Philadelphia commodities firm and treat their employees as pieces in an argument about nature and upbringing. Randolph believes that Billy Ray Valentine, a street hustler who is arrested after Louis Winthorpe mistakes him for a thief, could succeed if given the same advantages as the firm’s polished managing director. Mortimer doubts it, so the brothers make a one-dollar wager and secretly exchange the men’s lives. Winthorpe has a townhouse, a butler, a fiancée and a place among the Dukes’ business associates; Valentine has been asking for spare change outside the private club those associates frequent.
The experiment is rigged from the start. Clarence Beeks, a fixer on the Dukes’ payroll, plants marked money on Winthorpe. After Beeks speaks to an officer, police also find drugs in his jacket. Winthorpe is arrested, dismissed and locked out of his home. His fiancée Penelope turns away from him, and even Coleman pretends not to recognize his former employer because the Dukes own the house and pay his wages. Valentine, meanwhile, is bailed out and offered Winthorpe’s job, salary and rooms. He is unsure how to behave in the unfamiliar setting, but quickly reads the market and earns the brothers’ respect. When his old acquaintances treat the townhouse as a party stop, he sends them away and tells Coleman they were taking advantage of him.
Ophelia first appears to Winthorpe as another part of the setup: Beeks pays her to kiss the disgraced broker and ask him for drugs in front of Penelope. She admits the joke and expects him to pay her for the cab ride, yet she changes her mind after he has lost his home and money. She has saved $42,000 toward retirement and is willing to shelter him while he tries to recover. The film lets her practical bargain coexist with real concern. Coleman also becomes an ally, moving from reluctant cooperation with the Dukes to helping Winthorpe and Valentine once the brothers’ wager is exposed.
At the firm’s Christmas party, Winthorpe tries to plant drugs in Valentine’s desk and prove that the new executive has been corrupted. Valentine catches him, but the confrontation only makes Winthorpe look more desperate. After he flees, Valentine lights one of Winthorpe’s joints and, from a bathroom stall, hears Randolph and Mortimer celebrate the experiment and plan to cast him back onto the street. They intend to dispose of Valentine after Beeks delivers the crop report. After a failed attempt with his gun, Winthorpe overdoses at Ophelia’s apartment. Valentine and Ophelia find him and take him to the townhouse for help.
When the four learn that the Dukes are paying Beeks for an early copy of the Agriculture Department’s orange crop report, the wager turns into a plan for revenge. The report will shape prices for frozen concentrated orange juice futures. The group boards Beeks’s New Year’s Eve train in costume, switches his briefcase and escapes after a gorilla in a baggage car knocks him unconscious. They leave Beeks dressed in a gorilla outfit and confined with the animal, then Valentine impersonates him in a hotel parking garage and hands the Dukes a forged report predicting a poor harvest. The real report stays with the conspirators. Before Winthorpe leaves for New York, Ophelia and Coleman add their savings to the cash the group has obtained from the Dukes.
On the trading floor, Winthorpe explains the mechanics to Valentine as the brothers act on the false report. They buy orange juice contracts heavily, and other traders follow, pushing the price up. Valentine and Winthorpe sell at that inflated price. When the actual report announces a normal crop, the market falls; the pair buy contracts back cheaply while the Dukes cannot meet the margin call on their enormous position. The climax makes the financial maneuver visible as a crowd scene: the brothers keep ordering purchases as prices rise, then cross the floor in panic when the numbers turn against them. The partners’ wager is echoed in the final exchange of one dollar between Valentine and Winthorpe, while Randolph collapses and Mortimer rages after their assets are seized.
The last image moves the surviving group to a tropical beach: Valentine, Winthorpe, Ophelia and Coleman share the wealth, while Beeks and the gorilla are shipped away together. Director John Landis placed the film in the tradition of older comedies about class, comparing its exchange of identities with The Prince and the Pauper. The brothers’ petty rivalry also had a concrete starting point: writer Timothy Harris played tennis with two wealthy brothers who argued over tiny expenses. Their competitive stinginess suggested men who would turn someone else’s life into a wager. Landis cast Jamie Lee Curtis as Ophelia after finding her funny and sharp in person, despite studio resistance to an actress associated with horror films. For the finale, the production used the commodities exchange at the World Trade Center after being refused permission in Chicago. Landis recalled that most of the floor traders were real market workers, whose elbows and jostling made the staged frenzy comparatively restrained.

