Behind the film
- Year
- 2019
- Director
- Noah Baumbach
- Writers
- Noah Baumbach
- Runtime
- 2h 16m
- Genres
- Comedy drama, Romance
- Production
- Heyday Films, Netflix
- Country
- United States, United Kingdom
- Cast
- Scarlett Johansson, Adam Driver, Laura Dern, Alan Alda, Ray Liotta, Azhy Robertson, Julie Hagerty, Merritt Wever
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Charlie Barber directs a small New York theatre company, where his wife Nicole is also its leading actor. The film first gives their relationship through two affectionate lists: the habits and gestures each values in the other. Those memories sit against the present, when they are already separating and have been asked by a mediator to read their lists aloud. Nicole cannot bring herself to do it, and they abandon the exercise.
Nicole accepts a television pilot in Los Angeles, a chance to return to acting on camera and be near her mother and sister. Charlie assumes the stay is temporary and remains in New York as his play moves toward Broadway. Their son Henry travels with Nicole, and the couple initially try to keep the break informal so that he is spared the worst of it. But Los Angeles quickly becomes more than a work trip. Nicole wants to stay, while Charlie believes their family belongs in New York.
Nicole’s producer encourages her to speak with Nora Fanshaw, a confident divorce lawyer who helps Nicole put long-suppressed grievances into words. She describes feeling overshadowed by Charlie’s ambition, even as she had helped build his theatre company, and she raises his affair with stage manager Mary Ann. When Charlie comes to Los Angeles, excited by a major fellowship and expecting a family visit, Nicole serves him with divorce papers. He first considers hiring Jay Marotta, an aggressive attorney who treats the case as a contest, then turns instead to Bert Spitz, a calmer lawyer who urges him to preserve a workable relationship with Nicole.
Charlie learns Nicole intends to remain in California and fears losing regular time with Henry. Bert advises him to rent an apartment nearby. A meeting between the lawyers could settle the dispute, but Nicole argues that Henry’s life is rooted in Los Angeles. Charlie refuses to become a visitor to his son, fires Bert and hires Jay. In court, Nora and Jay recast the couple’s private history as arguments about fitness: Charlie’s distance and affair are set against claims about Nicole’s drinking and her access to his email. When the parents still cannot agree, the judge keeps Henry in Los Angeles for the time being and appoints an evaluator to observe each home.
Nicole visits Charlie’s nearly empty Los Angeles apartment because she wants to talk without the lawyers. Their conversation starts as an attempt to stop the conflict from worsening, then moves through old grievances about work, fidelity, selfishness and the lives they each thought they had agreed to share. They accuse each other of taking more than they gave. Charlie tells Nicole he wishes she were dead, then breaks down in tears and apologizes for what he has said; she comforts him. Their attempt to negotiate privately has exposed grievances that their lawyers cannot settle.
During the evaluator’s visit, Charlie tries to cook dinner and keep Henry comfortable under observation. Henry asks him to show the knife trick he does for Nicole: Charlie pretends to cut himself, then retracts the small blade before it reaches his arm. Reluctantly, Charlie describes the joke to the evaluator and demonstrates it, but this time the blade does not retract fully and cuts him. He keeps making small talk while blood spreads through his sleeve, then struggles to bandage the wound after the evaluator leaves. He collapses on the kitchen floor as Henry comes in for a glass of milk.
They eventually finalize the divorce. The agreement gives Nicole the Los Angeles home base she wants, and Charlie accepts a residency at UCLA so he can live nearer to Henry. Later, Henry finds Nicole’s original list of what she loved about Charlie and asks his father to read it. Charlie does so, while Nicole watches from the doorway. By the next Halloween, both parents have built lives in Los Angeles. Nicole lets Charlie take Henry home on her scheduled evening and stops to tie his untied shoe, a brief gesture that recalls their affection without suggesting that they will reunite.
Baumbach constructed the opening lists to give the family a shared past before showing its separation. He and cinematographer Robbie Ryan also keep the visual perspective close to Nicole and Charlie when lawyers speak: the camera watches from the parents’ side of the room rather than moving behind their representatives. The apartments carry another part of the story. Their Brooklyn home has a stage-like entrance and the accumulated belongings of a marriage; it looks stripped when Charlie signs the agreement. His Los Angeles apartment divides kitchen and living room with a half-wall, resembling a split set. Baumbach and the actors rehearsed the 11-page confrontation with intricately timed movement and overlapping dialogue. Music gives the two another connection: each sings from Stephen Sondheim’s Company separately. Charlie’s “Being Alive” lets him express feelings through a song he knows, while Nicole performs with her mother and sister, drawing on a different family history.

