V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
Little Big Man poster
V4mp Cinema

Little Big Man

1970 · Arthur Penn

Dustin Hoffman plays Jack Crabb, a white man raised by Cheyenne people who moves between their world and settler society. Arthur Penn's Western follows his marriages, failed careers and encounters with Custer, as the elderly Jack tells a historian how he survived a violent past.

Comedy dramaFlashbackWesternHistorical

Behind the film

Year
1970
Director
Arthur Penn
Writers
Calder Willingham, Thomas Louis Berger
Genres
Comedy drama, Flashback, Western, Historical
Production
CBS, Cinema Center Films
Country
United States
Cast
Dustin Hoffman, Faye Dunaway, Chief Dan George, Martin Balsam, Richard Mulligan, Cal Bellini, Thayer David, Aimée Eccles

About the film

Contains story spoilers.

The 121-year-old Jack Crabb tells a historian about his Cheyenne childhood with Old Lodge Skins, a preacher's household, a medicine show and gunslinging. Seeing Wild Bill Hickok kill makes him abandon that career. The narrator's extraordinary age required a face and hands to match. Dick Smith's career account describes six weeks spent sculpting overlapping makeup appliances for Hoffman. Smith had previously experimented with extreme aging and blinking eyelids for Dark Shadows; that work helped prepare him for Jack. The technique also travelled in the other direction: pieces made for Little Big Man, including eyelids and a head appliance, were later reused for House of Dark Shadows.

Jack's crowded life comes from Thomas Berger's novel, adapted for the screen by Calder Willingham. Interviewed by Andrew Ward for American Heritage in 1999, Berger explained that he wanted one man's story to contain the legends of the Old West. His gunfighter and battlefield episodes could stand for encounters too numerous for Jack to experience individually. He researched through books and articles, using historians to restrain his narrator's extravagance. Jack himself had a less scholarly ancestor: a boastful barroom character named Kit Carson in William Saroyan's The Time of Your Life. Penn described the film in terms of divided identity. In the archived broadcast Arthur Penn: Themes and Variants, he explains that Jack's intimate involvement in two cultures supplies the substance of the story. His account places the emphasis on a survivor moving between those worlds, with Jack's perspective taking precedence over historical accuracy. The familiar names and battles belong to a fictional life told by a man claiming to have been there.

A dishonest partner ruins Jack's store. His wife Olga's abduction draws him back to the Cheyenne. He joins Custer's cavalry, deserts during an attack on civilians and marries Sunshine after helping deliver her child. Hoffman had to keep finding Jack through these changes of circumstance. Paul Tatara's Turner Classic Movies account draws on Faye Dunaway's autobiography, Looking for Gatsby, for a glimpse of his preparation. Dunaway remembered him trying to make every take fresh. Just before action, he would imitate Earl Scheib's car-painting advertisements, adopting their nasal voice and rattling through a sales pitch. When Penn called action, Hoffman would drop the commercial and enter the scene. Dunaway describes the abrupt switch as something remarkable to watch. Her memory concerns the moment before a take, when a deliberately corny routine helped him stay loose. Tatara also describes the location shoot across Montana, California and Alberta, where outdoor filming in Canadian cold and snow became especially exhausting for the cast.

At Washita, the cavalry kills Sunshine, her child and her sisters. Jack saves Old Lodge Skins but cannot bring himself to kill Custer in revenge. Drinking and isolation follow. Kimberly Lindbergs's essay for the National Film Registry connects the killing of civilians with the Vietnam War and the My Lai massacre. She reads Jack as a weak, frequently unsuccessful antihero, reversing the Western convention in which a white outsider rescues Native people. Her discussion of Richard Mulligan's Custer makes the same reversal through performance: the general becomes an egocentric figure bent on destruction, far from earlier heroic screen versions. Lindbergs places Chief Dan George's Old Lodge Skins at the emotional centre of the film's depiction of Native people.

Penn described resistance to that sympathy when he spoke at the Museum of the Moving Image in 1994. He recalled spending six years trying to get Little Big Man made. In his account, studio production offices inflated its estimated cost because they opposed a film sympathetic to Native people; the figures then frightened studio heads who might otherwise support it. He said the completed film came in below that inflated estimate. His recollection connects the obstacles to making the picture with the Hollywood version of Western history he wanted to challenge. Music offered another way to change that familiar version. Penn explained that he chose blues played by one singer with a guitar, rejecting the stock rhythmic cues studios had repeatedly used for Native characters. He believed an ethnic musical sound could work across that imposed boundary. The choice came from his own enthusiasm for blues, rather than an attempt to reproduce the conventional Hollywood sound of an Indian Western.

Jack finally defeats Custer by telling the truth about the force awaiting him at Little Bighorn. Custer distrusts him and attacks. Younger Bear saves Jack, repaying a life debt. Old Lodge Skins then lies down to die, but rain interrupts; he gets up for dinner. Jack dismisses his historian. Berger distinguished the film's Custer from his own in that 1999 interview: the novel allows the general soldierly courage and dignity, while the film's portrayal is more hostile. Another change concerns Old Lodge Skins. Berger recalled weeping as he wrote the character's death in the novel. The film lets Jack's adoptive grandfather live beyond his intended farewell.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.