Behind the film
- Year
- 1944
- Director
- George Cukor
- Writers
- John Van Druten, Walter Reisch, John L. Balderston, Patrick Hamilton
- Runtime
- 1h 54m
- Genres
- Crime thriller, Film noir, Drama, Melodrama
- Production
- Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Charles Boyer, Ingrid Bergman, Joseph Cotten, May Whitty, Angela Lansbury, Maude Fealy, Terry Moore, Barbara Everest
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Paula Alquist was a teenager when her aunt Alice, a celebrated opera singer who raised her, was strangled in their London home. The murder was never solved, and Paula was sent to Italy to recover. Ten years later, she has studied singing and falls in love with Gregory Anton, a pianist she has known for only a short time. After their honeymoon at Lake Como, Gregory tells her that he has long wanted to live in a fashionable London square. Paula suggests the empty house she inherited from Alice, not knowing that Gregory chose her partly to gain access to it. The return unsettles her: familiar rooms bring back the murder, and Gregory directs that Alice's belongings be stored upstairs. The house becomes both their home and the place where Paula's past keeps pressing into the present.
Paula finds a letter hidden in Alice's sheet music. It is from a man named Sergius Bauer, who asked to see her aunt two days before the killing. Gregory reacts sharply when Paula reads the name aloud, then takes the letter away. A few months later, he gives her a brooch before they visit the Tower of London and warns her not to wear it because the clasp needs repair. Paula puts it in her purse anyway. When she later cannot find it, Gregory treats the loss as proof that she is forgetful. He moves a painting from its usual place and accuses her of shifting it, and when she protests, he says she has done the same thing before. Each incident leaves Paula trying to reconstruct what happened while her husband supplies a confident account that makes her doubt her own.
The house has noises and changes that Paula cannot explain. At night, after Gregory says he is leaving for his music studio, the lights in her room dim and she hears footsteps overhead. Gregory has actually slipped back inside and gone to the sealed upper floor, where he searches Alice's possessions for jewels stolen the night she died. The gas lamps respond as he uses them upstairs, while Paula remains below with no explanation for what she sees and hears. Gregory hires Nancy as a maid and tells her to follow his instructions rather than Paula's. Paula's isolation deepens as Gregory discourages outings and visitors, turning her discomfort into another supposed symptom. A neighbor, Miss Thwaites, notices that something is wrong, while Scotland Yard detective Brian Cameron begins to look into the old murder.
Brian knew Alice as an admired singer and recognises her face in Paula. He investigates the case and learns that valuable jewels disappeared from the house when Alice was killed. Gregory works to keep him away from Paula, while also arranging situations that make her appear unstable. At a concert, he tells her that his watch has gone missing and lets her discover it in her own purse. Paula breaks down in front of the guests. Back at home, Gregory tells her that the letter she found never existed and links her fear to her mother's supposed mental illness. He says doctors will examine her and that he plans to have her committed to an asylum. By this point, Paula has reason to suspect that objects are being moved, but Gregory has made every public encounter a test she seems to fail. The detective's questions are the first serious alternative to the story her husband has imposed.
Brian and a constable follow Gregory after he leaves, but lose him in the fog. They later learn that he has been entering the adjoining empty house and crossing the roof to reach his own attic. Brian goes inside while Gregory is upstairs searching through Alice's furniture. He finds that Gregory's gun is missing, and Paula recovers the letter her husband denied existed. Brian compares the handwriting with a note Gregory sent to a concert host and identifies him as Bauer, an accompanist who knew Alice. While they piece this together, Gregory finally finds the jewels sewn into one of Alice's opera costumes. He tears them free, and the gaslights brighten as he turns off the lamps upstairs. Brian returns through the roof and confronts Gregory, who fights him. When Paula hears a gunshot, she rushes to the attic and finds her husband tied to a chair.
Paula turns Gregory's claim of her instability back on him, taunting him as he sits bound. He confesses to Alice's murder and explains that the jewels drove him to it. Brian reassures her that she is sane. The letter, jewels, attic route and gaslights now form a chain of evidence Paula can trust. Gregory's control relied on isolating her from anyone who could confirm what she noticed; once Brian puts the clues together, the house becomes a place where the crime can be named.

