V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
Forgetting Sarah Marshall poster
V4mp Cinema

Forgetting Sarah Marshall

2008 · 1h 52m · Nicholas Stoller

Composer Peter Bretter travels to Hawaii after television actress Sarah Marshall ends their relationship. His escape becomes an awkward shared holiday when Sarah arrives with rock star Aldous Snow. Hotel concierge Rachel offers Peter another connection, while his unfinished Dracula puppet musical gives him something of his own to pursue.

Romantic comedyComedy drama

Behind the film

Year
2008
Director
Nicholas Stoller
Writers
Jason Segel
Runtime
1h 52m
Genres
Romantic comedy, Comedy drama
Production
Apatow Productions
Country
United States
Cast
Jason Segel, Kristen Bell, Mila Kunis, Russell Brand, Bill Hader, Maria Thayer, Jack McBrayer, Steve Landesberg

About the film

Contains story spoilers.

Peter finds Sarah and Aldous at the same resort and grows close to Rachel. She encourages him to sing from his Dracula opera. Sarah reveals how disconnected she felt from Peter; her own relationship with Aldous then collapses. Peter briefly considers returning to Sarah but stops because he loves Rachel. His confession hurts Rachel, who sends him away. Back in Los Angeles, he finishes and stages his puppet opera. Rachel attends opening night, congratulates him and leaves him to enjoy the success. She then returns to his dressing room to say she misses him, and they kiss.

Jason Segel described the screenplay as an amalgam of relationships from the previous ten years. That distinction matters for Sarah: she belongs to a fictional relationship assembled from several experiences, rather than a direct portrait of one former partner. Segel felt the film would be less interesting if she were simply vilified for leaving Peter. His approach allows the breakup to change shape as Peter learns more about how Sarah experienced their life together. Kristen Bell found a particular way into Sarah through the cancellation of her television series. Bell recalled that Veronica Mars had been cancelled two weeks before she filmed Sarah responding to the loss of Crime Scene: Scene of the Crime. She drew on her own insecurity about whether another acting job would come, then imagined expressing it without her usual politeness. Bell also understood Peter as someone attached to an idea of Sarah, and thought the relationship that brought out his better qualities mattered more than that ideal.

Mila Kunis saw Rachel as someone who was not searching for a replacement boyfriend. After her earlier relationship ended, Rachel stayed in Hawaii and happened to meet Peter. In Kunis’s account, they bond because both had lost a sense of themselves while involved with someone else. She described the romance as developing very quickly, over roughly five days, rather than a carefully planned search for love. Sarah’s television work gave Segel a separate comic setting inside the film. He recalled that she originally appeared in a sitcom, before the writers switched her to a crime series to reflect the popularity of forensic dramas. Crime Scene: Scene of the Crime pairs her young detective with Billy Baldwin. Segel said Bell’s Veronica Mars background was not the reason for choosing that format, though she could play it.

Nicholas Stoller began with a firm screenplay. He wanted scenes that would work if the actors performed only what was written, then added improvisation and jokes suggested on set. His estimate was that about 60 to 70 percent of the finished film was scripted. Jonah Hill and Paul Rudd’s scenes gave more room to improvise. Stoller, Rodney Rothman and Shauna Robertson also offered lines and directions for the actors to explore. The shared joke writing drew on television comedy. Bell remembered improvisation as a new acting challenge, something she had wanted to try without feeling confident enough to announce it. Speaking to Diablo Cody, she described the Apatow approach as heavily improvised and said it kept her alert. Her recollection puts more emphasis on improvisation than Stoller’s estimate does. Bell’s account stresses the demands on the performer; Stoller’s focuses on the balance between a finished script and additional jokes.

Segel deliberately chose Hawaii as a place where he wanted to work. After selling the pitch, he rented a house there for a month and finished the script. Staying at the hotel used as a location made the working day direct: he could get up and go to the set, then spend evenings with the other performers and crew. He especially enjoyed that camaraderie. Radio Free interviewed Segel and Kunis while filming Hawaii bar scenes in Los Angeles. Turtle Bay Resort was among the locations used on Oahu’s North Shore, where much of the film was shot. Bell recalled spending about two and a half months in Hawaii, with the four leads arriving roughly two and a half weeks early for exercise and yoga. Stoller remembered about three months there and a two-week rehearsal period. Rehearsals produced comic material, including the discussion of Sarah’s film about a deadly mobile phone.

Peter’s creative ambition changed during development. Stoller recalled an earlier draft ending with the musician playing a pretty song for Rachel. When Segel told him about his real wish to make a serious Dracula puppet musical, Stoller urged him to make that Peter’s dream. Segel had written a version of the bar song around age twenty. The stranger ambition gave the ending a specific goal rooted in something the writer actually wanted to make. Peter Brooke’s Creature Shop team built Dracula and Van Helsing from Jackson De Govia’s drawings. Segel learned to operate Dracula himself. Looking back years later, Segel described youthful confidence as part of getting that ending made. He had assumed a lavish Dracula puppet musical was an obvious way to finish the movie. With more experience, he thought, a filmmaker might become cautious enough to question an idea before giving it a chance.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.