Behind the film
- Year
- 2011
- Director
- Glenn Ficarra, John Requa
- Writers
- Dan Fogelman
- Runtime
- 1h 58m
- Genres
- Comedy drama, Romantic comedy, Teen, Coming-of-age
- Production
- Warner Bros. Entertainment
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Steve Carell, Ryan Gosling, Julianne Moore, Emma Stone, John Carroll Lynch, Marisa Tomei, Kevin Bacon, Jonah Bobo
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Cal Weaver thinks his life is settled until Emily, his high-school sweetheart and wife of twenty-five years, asks for a divorce during dinner. She admits that she slept with David Lindhagen, an accountant at her workplace. On the drive home Cal refuses to discuss it and, when she keeps talking, climbs out of the moving car. Their children, thirteen-year-old Robbie and younger Molly, soon learn that the marriage is ending. Cal leaves the family home for an apartment, where the familiar routines that once defined him are suddenly gone. His closest friend Bernie also cuts him off because Bernie’s wife has taken Emily’s side. Cal spends his evenings at a bar, loudly recounting the affair to strangers while noticing Jacob Palmer’s effortless success with women. Even the move itself reflects his denial: he treats the separation as a temporary interruption rather than a change the whole household must absorb.
Jacob is a polished regular at the bar, but his confidence hides a recent rejection by Hannah, a law-school graduate whose usual boyfriend has failed to propose after she passes the bar exam. Jacob sees Cal floundering and offers to teach him how to approach women. The lessons begin with a new wardrobe and continue with Jacob demonstrating his rehearsed charm. Cal’s first real success comes when he abandons the lines and speaks honestly to Kate, a woman at the bar; they go home together. That one encounter gives him the nerve to date more freely, though the new attention does not solve the reason he is hurting. He still wants Emily back, while she is trying to understand why she had an affair and whether she wants a future with David.
The film keeps the children’s crushes tangled with the adults’ choices. Robbie is devoted to Jessica, the seventeen-year-old babysitter, while Jessica is secretly in love with Cal. Cal’s first effort to win Emily back seems to work when they meet at Robbie’s parent-teacher conference: she notices his clothes and confidence, and the two reconnect in the hallway. Then the teacher opens the classroom door. She is Kate, the woman Cal slept with, and she tells Emily about it. The reunion collapses into an argument outside the school. Cal’s attempt to become attractive to other women has given him confidence, but his choices make reconciliation harder, and Robbie’s classroom behaviour has already brought the family back into contact under the worst possible circumstances.
Jacob’s own story turns when Hannah returns to the bar after her boyfriend offers her a job at his law firm instead of the marriage proposal she expected. She kisses Jacob, and their flirtation becomes a relationship. For a while Jacob tries to use the same seduction routine on her, but Hannah sees through it and the two discover a more sincere connection. Meanwhile Robbie makes a public declaration of love to Jessica at school, inspired by his father’s advice to keep trying. Jessica rejects him because she wants someone older, and the gap between what Robbie hopes for and what she feels becomes painful. She asks a classmate for advice and takes suggestive photographs, intending to give them to Cal. Her parents, Bernie and Claire, find the pictures and mistake them as evidence of a relationship with him.
Cal and his children arrange a backyard gathering with a makeshift mini-golf course to remind Emily of their first date. The plan brings the separate stories into one place: Jacob arrives with Hannah, and Jacob discovers that his girlfriend is Cal and Emily’s daughter, Hannah. Cal realizes that the man he knows from the bar is dating her. He is shocked that Jacob is dating her and orders them apart. Bernie and Jessica arrive, and the misunderstanding over the photographs erupts. David then turns up to return Emily’s sweater, prompting a brawl involving Cal, Jacob, Bernie and David before police break it up. The family is left more divided than before. Later Jacob tells Cal that he loves Hannah and has changed his view of relationships. Cal remains wary because he knows Jacob’s former habits, but Jacob’s respect for him as a father begins to soften the rejection.
At Robbie’s eighth-grade graduation, he is the salutatorian and uses his speech to say that he no longer believes in true love. Cal interrupts and tells the audience how he fell for Emily, admitting that he cannot guarantee what happens next but will keep trying to repair their marriage. Robbie regains some hope and renews his feelings for Jessica; after the ceremony she gives him the envelope of photographs as a gesture of support. Cal also gives Jacob and Hannah his blessing. The film leaves Cal and Emily talking and laughing together, without showing a definite reconciliation. Their conversation makes room for the possibility of starting again, while the other couples have to face the difference between wanting love and being able to make a relationship work.

