Behind the film
- Year
- 1998
- Director
- Brad Silberling
- Writers
- Dana Stevens, Wim Wenders, Peter Handke, Richard Reitinger
- Runtime
- 1h 54m
- Genres
- Romance, Fantasy, Drama
- Production
- Regency Enterprises
- Country
- United States, Germany
- Cast
- Nicolas Cage, Meg Ryan, Andre Braugher, Dennis Franz, Colm Feore, Robin Bartlett, Kim Murphy, Alexander Gould
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Brad Silberling’s City of Angels places its angels above the traffic of Los Angeles: on rooftops, freeway signs and billboards, watching over people who cannot usually see them. Seth and his fellow angel Cassiel guide the dying toward the next life and try to comfort those left behind. They keep mental notes on the lives they observe, but they lack the senses that make those lives feel immediate. At dawn and sunset they gather by the ocean, listening to a sound that humans cannot hear. Seth’s questions begin with small things: what it is like to taste fruit, feel rain or touch another person. He has spent an immeasurable time close to humanity without being able to take part in it.
The film’s first encounter with Maggie comes during an operation, as Seth waits to accompany her patient into death. He is impressed by the surgeon’s effort to save the man and her anguish when she cannot. She is left asking whether she could have done more and whether all her skill can matter when life is beyond her control. Seth makes himself visible to her so he can comfort her. The moment alters both their routines: Maggie must decide whether the man standing beside her is real, while Seth discovers that his presence can reach one particular person. The film keeps that first connection tied to her work as a surgeon and to the death she cannot repair.
Maggie is already involved with Jordan Ferris, another doctor, but the relationship does not settle her doubts about medicine or about what she wants from life. Seth keeps appearing, listens to her thoughts and tries to understand why people can feel pain so sharply and still keep moving. They talk in the hospital and among the city’s ordinary spaces. Maggie learns that Seth calls himself a messenger, though he cannot offer her the familiar details of a human life: a home, a history, even a last name. As he grows attached to her, the gap between what he knows about human feeling and what he can experience becomes harder to ignore. Cassiel watches his colleague turn curiosity into a choice that could end his angelic existence.
Seth meets Nathaniel Messinger, one of Maggie’s patients, who recognises what he is. Nathaniel tells him that he was once an angel and chose to become human by “falling.” He has built a life with his wife, Theresa, and their family; he is a living example of the bargain rather than a messenger sent to push Seth toward it. Nathaniel talks about ordinary pleasures with an appetite Seth cannot share yet. His example makes the choice concrete: Seth would give up immortality, the ability to appear and disappear, and his role beside Cassiel in exchange for a body that can feel but also be hurt and age. Maggie, meanwhile, is pulled between her uncertain attachment to Jordan and the strange, unearned closeness she feels with Seth.
Seth makes his decision by jumping from a high building. When he wakes as a human, pain arrives first, followed by the other sensations he has only watched from a distance. He touches his face, feels the rain and learns what food tastes like. The change also removes the powers he relied on: when he goes to find Maggie, he cannot simply appear at her side. She has gone to her uncle’s cabin near Lake Tahoe. Seth has no money or practical knowledge of travel, and the journey leaves him cold, wet and vulnerable. After hitching a ride, he reaches the cabin. Maggie understands that he chose mortality to be with her, and they spend the night together.
In the morning Maggie rides her bicycle into town while Seth showers. She takes in the open air and sunlight with the abandon of someone who has just found the answer to a question she had been carrying. Riding back with her arms spread and her eyes closed, she does not see a logging truck crossing the road. The collision leaves her mortally injured. Seth reaches her, but he no longer has the ability to see the angels who guide the dying. Maggie can see the angel waiting to accompany her, and she is no longer afraid. She tells him that when the angels ask what she loved most about being alive, her answer will be Seth. Then she dies. The loss arrives immediately after he has gained the human senses he wanted, tying his first full day as a man to the fragility he could once only observe.
Cassiel visits Seth after Maggie’s death. Seth asks whether his loss is punishment for leaving, and Cassiel tells him it is not. He has time to grieve, and the film shows that his choice has not become meaningless simply because it did not give him a lasting romance. At the ocean, Seth runs into the water and feels the waves at dawn. Cassiel remains nearby and watches him with a smile. The closing scene returns to the angels’ coastal gathering, but Seth now belongs to the human world he once watched from a distance. John Seale’s cinematography helps mark that change through the contrast between the angels’ shadowless presence and close views of skin, hands, rain and food. The Los Angeles streets and mountain cabin give the story a physical geography that Seth must learn to cross on foot and by ride.

